Skip to main content
Chefs Studio Journal

Christmas Guests to January Regulars: Fill Your Quiet Month

On behalf of Ian McAndrew

In Brief: Most of the people sitting at your Christmas party tables have never eaten with you before, and most of them won’t come back unless you give them a reason. Get their details with permission, show them a little of your real cooking, and hand them a January invitation before they leave the building. January is still going to be quiet. A few dozen returning faces is what stops it being a disaster.

How do you stop January killing your margin? You start filling it in December, while the people who could fill it are sitting in your dining room in paper hats.

Every kitchen knows the pattern. December is long, loud and profitable, and then the doors open on 2 January to an empty book, a tired brigade and a walk-in full of stock nobody ordered for. Most of us treat that as weather. It isn’t. A good part of January’s trade walked through your door a few weeks earlier, ate your sprouts, pulled a cracker and went home without anyone asking them to come back.

Who is actually at the table?

Christmas party guests are a different animal from your regulars. Someone else booked. Someone else picked the date, and usually someone else chose from the set menu. They are there because the office went, not because they chose you.

That set menu matters too. It was written to get long tables out without the pass falling over, which is the right call in December. It just isn’t your cooking, and the guests don’t know the difference. They leave thinking they’ve had you, on the strength of turkey and a pudding you plated forty at a time.

So you have a room full of people who have never eaten with you before, who have seen the least representative version of what you do, and who are about to go into a month where they are skint, and half of them have given up drinking. If you do nothing, most of them are gone.

Get the details, and get them properly.

You have the booker’s details. You don’t have the other twenty people around the table, and they are the ones you want.

  • Put a small card on each table or with the coffee: a line about January and a QR code to join your list.
  • Have servers mention it once, at coffee, in one sentence. Not at the start, not three times.
  • A draw for dinner for two in January gives people a reason to scan it there and then.
  • Ask for name and email, nothing more. The more boxes, the fewer sign-ups.
  • Ask permission and keep a record that they gave it. Don’t lift the booker’s guest list into your mailing list. It’s poor form, and it can land you in bother with the data rules.

Give them a reason that isn’t a discount.

The easy answer is a January discount. Two for one, 30% off, whatever the till can stand. It fills seats, it empties the margin, and it teaches people that you are worth visiting only when you are cheap. Those are the guests who vanish again in February.

Give them something that shows them your real cooking instead:

  • a short tasting of the actual menu on a midweek night
  • a chef’s table or kitchen counter evening, if you have the room
  • a glass of something on arrival, or a dish that isn’t on the menu yet
  • a set of dates, Tuesday to Thursday, so you are filling the nights that need it

The value they feel is higher than the cost you carry, and you stay in control of both. Price it properly before you print a single card. There is more on that in Menu Pricing Psychology and Filling Quiet Midweek Nights Without Killing Your Margin.

Hand it over at the table.

An email the morning after a party goes straight under the hangover and four hundred other festive emails. The invitation works best in the hand, while they are still warm, fed and in a decent mood.

So the handover happens at the table, and front of house needs to know exactly how it goes: who says it, when, and in what words. Put it in the pre-service briefing every party night through December. If your briefings drift, The 15-Minute Briefing That Saves Your Service is worth ten minutes of your time.

The kitchen can help without adding work on a busy night. Send the coffee out with one petit four from your proper menu and a card that says, plainly, This is what we cook the rest of the year. It costs pennies, and it tells them there is more to you than the turkey.

Plan January’s menu now, not on New Year’s Day.

You can only promise what you can afford to give, so write the January offer before the cards go out. Cost it dish by dish, check your GP, and make sure the brigade can deliver it on a quiet Tuesday with the rota you will actually have. The card you hand out in December is a promise. Make it one you can keep.

What goes on that menu is a post in itself: the last weeks of game, forced rhubarb, Seville oranges, Dry January and a rota for a quiet month. It’s all in this month’s Month Ahead, January Menu Planning: Start Before Christmas.

The reality check

This will not fill January. Nothing will. What it can do is take the edge off.

Say you feed 600 party guests across December, and one in twenty comes back in January with someone else. That’s 60 covers on nights you would otherwise have spent staring at the door, from people who now know what you can really do. Some of them will come back again, and that is how first-timers turn into regulars, which we wrote about in Turning First-Time Guests Into Regulars.

The paper hats go in the bin on Christmas Eve. Make sure your name doesn’t go with them.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I discount in January to get people back?

Only as a last resort. A straight discount fills seats with people who come for the price and leave with it. An invitation to try your real menu on a set of midweek dates gives better value to the guest and protects your GP.

When should the January invitation go out?

In hand, at the table, on the night. A follow-up email to people who signed up can go in the first week of January, when they are planning the month and the festive noise has died down.

How do I get details from guests who didn’t make the booking?

Ask them directly. A table card with a QR code, one line from the server at coffee and a small January prize draw will do most of the work. Ask permission and keep a record that they said yes.

Is this worth it for a small independent?

More so than for a group. A small place feels a thin January hardest, and a few dozen extra covers can be the difference between a bad month and a dangerous one. The cost is a stack of cards, a petit four and two minutes in the briefing.

What if we don’t do Christmas parties?

The same thinking works for any one-off booking: birthdays, christenings, corporate lunches, and wedding parties. Anyone who came because someone else chose you is a guest worth inviting back on their own terms.

Written by

Shaun Smith-Roberts

Chef, publisher and digital strategist, bringing professional kitchen experience together with food media, editorial development and practical digital thinking.

Read more about Shaun →

Subscribe to our list

See how Chefs.studio can help your kitchen.